Is the USA headed for Totalitarianism or Authoritarianism?

Below is the actual response to my actual question to ChatGPT, followed by brief comments.  You can look at this and decide for yourself whether the American Republican party wants totalitarianism or mere authoritarianism.  

Is authoritarianism the same as totalitarianism?

ChatGPT said:

Authoritarianism and totalitarianism are related but distinct concepts in political science. Both refer to systems of governance that concentrate power in the hands of a leader or a small group, but they differ in the extent and manner of control they exert over society.

Authoritarianism:

Authoritarianism is a form of government characterized by strong central power and limited political freedoms. Key features include:

1. Centralized Control: Power is concentrated in a single leader or a small group.
2. Limited Political Pluralism: Political opposition is often restricted or suppressed.
3. Control Over Civil Society: Some control over the media, public discourse, and civil society, but not total.
4. Limited Political Participation: Citizen participation in politics is restricted; elections, if they exist, are often not free or fair.
5. Rule by Law: The government operates under a framework of laws, but these laws may be manipulated to maintain control.

Examples of authoritarian regimes include various military juntas, absolute monarchies, and one-party states.

Totalitarianism:

Totalitarianism is an extreme form of authoritarianism that seeks to control every aspect of public and private life. Key features include:

1. Total Control Over Society: The government seeks to dominate all aspects of life, including the economy, education, art, science, private life, and morals of citizens.
2. Ideological Uniformity: The regime promotes an official ideology that is intended to penetrate and control all aspects of society and individual life.
3. Extensive Use of Propaganda: The state uses mass media, propaganda, and misinformation to control public opinion and behavior.
4. State Terror and Repression: Widespread use of terror, secret police, and surveillance to eliminate opposition and enforce conformity.
5. Centralized Economy: The government often controls or heavily regulates the economy to achieve its goals.

Examples of totalitarian regimes include Nazi Germany under Adolf Hitler, the Soviet Union under Joseph Stalin, and North Korea under the Kim dynasty.

Differences:

• Scope of Control: Authoritarian regimes exercise broad but not total control, often allowing some personal freedoms and private enterprise, while totalitarian regimes seek to control every aspect of life.
• Use of Ideology: Totalitarian regimes rely heavily on an official ideology to legitimize their rule and mobilize the populace, whereas authoritarian regimes may or may not have a strong ideological component.
• Level of Repression: Totalitarian regimes employ more extensive and systematic repression and surveillance to maintain control, often using state terror as a tool.

Similarities:

• Concentration of Power: Both systems centralize power in the hands of a few.
• Suppression of Political Opposition: Both seek to suppress political dissent and limit political freedoms.
• Lack of Democratic Processes: Both lack free and fair elections and restrict political participation.

Understanding these distinctions is crucial for analyzing different political systems and their impacts on societies.

_________________________

So there you have it. It's a nice response, and one that a person can use and remember.  I'm sure there are theorists with finer things to say.  This is not an exhaustive list of distinguishing marks.  But it allows one to ask intelligent questions about what is going on around us in the USA. 

Do the MAGA Republicans want the more granular level of control implied by totalitarianism, or do they just want arbitrary power that they can keep forever?